Sevita Blog

How to Choose a Foster Care Agency: 13 Tips + 10 Questions to Ask

Written by Sevita | Dec 20, 2024 1:43:30 PM

Choosing the right foster care agency is a crucial step for anyone considering becoming a foster parent

The process can feel overwhelming, but it's important to remember the profound impact fostering can have on your life and the lives of children in need. 

As Erin Page-Brown, a former foster parent, beautifully states:

"If you have a heart for this, if you have a heart to help, fostering will be such an impactful experience for you, changing your life for the better."

This journey requires dedication, compassion, and a willingness to open your heart and home to a child. The right foster care agency provides the support, resources, and guidance you need. They are your partner, helping you navigate this life-changing path. 

What Key Factors Should I Consider When Choosing a Foster Care Agency?

Choosing the right foster care agency is a big step that can shape your journey as a foster parent. 

So, what are the key factors when considering public or private options?

1. Licensing

One of the first things is to ensure the agency meets all state and federal licensing requirements. Proper licensing ensures the agency is legally allowed to operate and follows important safety regulations. You can find this information on their website or by asking them directly.

2. Support for Foster Parents 

Good support is crucial for your success as a foster parent. 

Look at the agency’s support programs to see if they cover everything you need to know, from handling everyday situations to dealing with emergencies. 

They should also direct you to preservice sessions. These should include information on trauma-informed care, behavior management, and the unique needs of children in therapeutic foster care

Knowing that help is always available can give you peace of mind. Additionally, see if they provide extra resources like counseling, educational support, and support groups for foster parents. 

These resources can be invaluable as you navigate the challenges and joys of fostering.

3. Agency Reputation and Reviews

An agency’s reputation can tell you a lot about what to expect. 

Do some research to learn about their history and standing in the community. Look for agencies with a strong presence and positive relationships with local organizations. 

Reviews and testimonials from current and former foster parents can give valuable insights into their experiences. Pay attention to comments about the level of support, communication, and overall satisfaction. 

4. Placement Philosophy and Approach

Understanding the agency’s approach to placing children with families is important. 

Ask how they match children with foster families and whether their philosophy aligns with your values and expectations. Some agencies focus on placing children with families with similar cultural or religious backgrounds, while others prioritize keeping siblings together

It's also good to know their policies on reunification, adoption, and long-term placements. 

For example, do they actively work towards reuniting children with their birth families when possible? 

Understanding these policies can help you decide if the agency’s approach fits your goals and values as a foster parent.

5. Communication and Transparency

Good communication is key in fostering. 

Evaluate how the agency communicates with foster parents. Ensure they provide clear, timely, and honest information. Ask about their process for addressing concerns or issues that may arise. It’s important to feel that you can ask questions and get honest answers. 

Find out if they regularly check in with foster families and how they handle updates about the children in your care. Agencies that are transparent about their processes and open to feedback are often the best partners!

6. Support for Children in Care

When evaluating a foster care agency, it's important to check whether it provides individualized support for children. 

Ask about access to educational resources, therapy, and extracurricular activities to aid in the child's development and well-being. The right agencies might have connections to these aids! 

This includes their strategies for helping children cope with past trauma, building resilience, and supporting their overall mental and emotional health. 

7. Ongoing Foster Parent Education

Although preservice sessions are necessary in every state, staying current on foster parenting education never hurts. 

That’s why it’s important to ask if the agency provides ongoing foster parent education opportunities. 

Continuous learning is important to stay updated on best practices and new developments in foster care. Agencies that offer workshops, online courses, and other educational resources demonstrate a commitment to supporting foster parents throughout their journey.

8. Substitute Care Availability

Every foster parent needs a break from time to time!

When choosing a foster care agency, it’s important to inquire if it offers substitute care services. 

Substitute care provides temporary relief for foster parents, allowing them to take breaks while ensuring the child’s needs are still met. 

Additionally, you’ll want to assess the qualifications and training of substitute care providers to ensure they are well-equipped to care for your child when you need a break.

9. Cultural Competency

When choosing a foster care agency, you’ll want to evaluate its commitment to cultural competency and inclusivity. 

This includes their strategies for matching children with families who respect and understand their cultural heritage and providing ongoing support to foster parents navigating cultural differences. 

Agencies prioritizing cultural competency ensure that children feel valued and understood, which is vital for their overall well-being and identity development.

10. Community Connections

Looking at the agency's relationships with local organizations and community resources is important in your decision-making process. 

Does the agency collaborate with schools, healthcare providers, and other support services? 

These connections can greatly benefit you and the child you welcome into your home. Strong community ties mean better access to essential services, like educational support, medical care, and extracurricular activities. 

Agencies with robust community connections are often better equipped to provide comprehensive support, helping to create a nurturing and well-rounded environment for children in foster care. 

11. Sibling Placements

When evaluating a foster care agency, inquire about its policies and practices regarding sibling placements. 

Understanding their approach to maintaining sibling bonds and relationships is crucial, as being placed with siblings can provide emotional stability and support for children in foster care.

Agencies focusing on sibling placements often have strategies to accommodate and support sibling groups, ensuring they can stay connected and maintain their important family ties.

12. Agency Size and Caseloads

The size of the agency and the average caseloads for social workers matters when choosing an agency!

How are they managing caseloads? If they're overworked, ensuring quality support and attention for each foster family may be tough. 

Larger agencies may have more resources, but smaller agencies may offer more personalized attention. 

13. Experience and Expertise

Look at the agency's experience and expertise in foster care. 

An agency with a long history and specialized knowledge in therapeutic care, special needs, or sibling placements can offer valuable insights and support. 

Knowing that the agency has a proven track record of successful placements and positive outcomes can give you confidence in their ability to support you and the child in your care.

Questions to Ask Potential Foster Care Agencies

When considering partnering with a foster care agency, it is important to ask the right questions to ensure you choose the best fit for your family. 

Here are some essential questions to get you started:

1. “What is your process for matching children with foster families?”

Ask them to explain their process for determining the best fit for the child and the family. What criteria do they use? How do they assess compatibility? 

This can help you feel more confident that the agency is committed to creating successful and supportive placements.

2. “What kind of support and resources do you offer? 

Support is crucial for foster parents, so knowing what services are available to you is essential. 

Ask about the availability of support groups for foster parents, substitute care options, and additional helpful resources. 

Knowing you have a strong support system can significantly impact your fostering experience.

TIP: You can seek support before applying to see if a fostering program is a good fit. Mentor Foster Care, for example, offers free one-on-one sessions to get your questions answered by a foster care expert. Click here to reserve your session now.

3. “How do you handle emergencies or crises?”

Learn about their emergency protocols and support systems. Do they offer 24/7 assistance? What steps do they take to ensure you have the help you need in urgent situations? 

Understanding their approach to handling emergencies can provide peace of mind and ensure you're prepared for any unexpected challenges.

4. “Can you provide references from current or past foster parents?”

Ask the agency if they can provide references from current or past foster parents. When you talk to these references, ask about their experiences and the support they received from the agency. 

Did they feel well-prepared and supported? Were their concerns addressed promptly and effectively? 

These conversations can help you understand what it's like to work with the agency.

5. “Can you verify your licensing?” 

Understanding the agency's licensing is crucial for ensuring they meet high standards of care and operation.

  • Licensing: Ask if the agency meets all state and federal licensing requirements. Proper licensing ensures that the agency is legally allowed to operate and follows important safety regulations.

6. “What is your policy on sibling placements?”

Ask the agency how it prioritizes keeping siblings together whenever possible. It's also good to learn about its approach to maintaining sibling bonds and relationships, even if the siblings can't be placed in the same home.

7. “How do you facilitate family reunification?”

Ask about the services and resources they provide to birth families to help make reunification possible. 

It’s also good to know how they balance the goal of reunification with the child’s best interests, ensuring the process is smooth and supportive for everyone involved. 

8. “What kind of financial support is available?”

Money matters when providing the best care for a child. 

Ask the agency about its financial support, such as stipends, expense reimbursements, and additional resources. Knowing what financial help is available can relieve the pressure and help you focus on caring for the child in care. 

It’s reassuring to know that you’ll have the support you need to meet their needs.

9. “How do you ensure placement stability?”

Ask the agency about their strategies for maintaining long-term placements and preventing disruptions. Do they have specific programs or support systems to help foster families navigate challenges and stay committed? 

It's important to understand how they handle situations when a placement doesn't work out. 

10. “What community connections does the agency have?”

Ask about their relationships with local organizations, schools, healthcare providers, and other support services. An agency with strong ties within the community can mean better access to essential resources and support for you and your child. 

Making Your Decision to Select a Foster Care Agency

After gathering all the necessary information and asking the right questions, it’s time to decide. 

This final step is crucial as it sets the foundation for your journey as a foster parent.

Comparing Foster Care Agencies

Creating a comparison chart is an effective way to help you choose an agency. This chart can help you evaluate the pros and cons of each agency side by side. 

Consider all your important factors, such as the level of support they offer, the comprehensiveness of their training programs, their reputation in the community, and the resources they provide. 

Comparing these aspects can help you see which agency aligns best with your needs and values. 

Remember, the goal is to find an agency to support and guide you throughout your fostering journey!

Trust Your Instincts

While it’s important to consider all the practical aspects, it’s equally important to trust your instincts. 

Go with the agency that feels right for you and your family. Think about how comfortable you feel with their staff and policies.  Do you feel supported and understood? Do their values align with yours? 

Trusting your instincts can help ensure you choose an agency where you feel confident and at ease, which is important for a positive fostering experience.

Prepare for the Journey Ahead

Once you’ve chosen an agency, it’s time to prepare for the fostering journey with a positive and open mindset.

Engage in all the available training and resources to equip yourself for success. Take advantage of support services, and don’t hesitate to ask for help when needed. 

Fostering can challenge you, but it’s also incredibly rewarding!

By preparing yourself and staying open to learning and growing, you can make a meaningful difference in the lives of the children in your care.

Finding a Foster Care Program in Your State 

Finding the right agency for you is the starting point of an incredible fostering journey. 

With Mentor Foster Care, you’ll get the support you need every step of the way.

Find a Mentor Foster Care location near you: